The false marriage between quantum mechanics and consciousness

 There are two main mysteries in our world: the real nature of physics (Quantum Mechanics) and consciousness. So, naturally, it has been conveinent to connect and almost equate the two: from the Copenhagen interpretation of Quantum Mechanics that attributes the process of apparent wavefunction collapse to a conscious observer, to Roger Penrose, who allows consciousness and free will escape the shackles of deterministic physics via the indeterminism and probabilistic nature of Quantum Physics.

I think these are false connections. Qunatum Darwinism does not require the presence of consciousness to explain the apparent collapse of the wavefunction, and points to what looks like a more probably explanation of the emergence of classical physics. And free will is such an ill-defined and almost tautological concept that it's almost futile to try to trace it. I believe most questions related to consciousness can be defined and investigated in a classical physical framework, and that our physical reality, with its quantum and classical models, requires nothing exhibiting consciousness to exist.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

For the Righteous Shall Inherit the Land (Part One)

The Best Defense - A Short Story

We cannot know if we have free will, and so maybe all science is broken